This may seem counterintuitive, but leaders need to stop trying to command the room.
If you’ve ever looked up advice on building a commanding presence or an executive presence, you’ve probably seen the same list.
- Dress for the part.
- Speak first so you set the frame.
- Take up space.
- Never let them see you sweat.
- And if all else fails, fake it till you make it.
I understand why the advice is popular. It’s simple, actionable, and promises that presence is something you can switch on.
But I think most of this advice is ridiculous and misses the point.
Why commanding presence advice backfires
Several years ago, I met with someone who wanted to work on her executive presence. Her boss had told her she was too deferential and meek, and that she needed a more commanding presence. It was harsh feedback for a kind and generous person who wanted to step into more senior roles.
When we talked about how we would work together, I explained that I take an inside-out approach. We wouldn’t focus on tactics or techniques. We’d do the hard work of exploring her beliefs and values so she could build self-awareness and learn to show up as the best version of herself.
She decided to work with another coach because she wanted to focus on the tactical side of presence. That coach taught her the advice you’ve probably heard too.
About a year later, she called me, after someone we both knew told her to reach back out. It turns out the tactical approach backfired. She’d tried to make big, bold, dramatic changes that didn’t match who she was, and the changes rubbed people the wrong way.
I see this all the time when people work on themselves and their leadership. They fall for the idea that change is merely tactical, so they set out to change behaviors before they’ve tackled the beliefs that drive them.
A commanding presence is about so much more than tactics. It’s about being grounded in who you are and confident in your unique abilities. But nearly all of the advice on presence treats it like a performance, a show you put on when you walk into the room. People can tell when you’re putting on a show. They might not be able to name it, but they sense the choreography, and they don’t trust it. When someone performs for us, we feel manipulated instead of led, so we start watching the performance and stop listening to the person.
Here are five popular pieces of advice that backfire for exactly that reason:
- Strike a power pose. This is the one I find most ridiculous. The idea is to stand like a superhero for two minutes before a big meeting, feet apart and hands on your hips. It took off after a well-known 2010 study and a hugely popular TED talk suggested the pose could raise your confidence and even change your body chemistry. It sounded too good to be true, and it mostly was. When researchers repeated the study with more people, those effects didn’t hold up. The most they found was that some people feel a little more powerful. And even if you do, nobody in the room experiences your pose. They experience how you treat them once you walk in. (Here’s a summary of the research.)
- Speak first. I’m constantly amazed when leaders think they should do all the talking. They believe that if they talk first, they set the frame and everyone will then see you as the leader. It sounds decisive. But when the most senior person speaks first, everyone else starts adjusting to what you said. The bold people go quiet, the cautious ones agree, and the ideas you needed most never come out.
- Never show doubt. The thinking is that leaders should always look certain, because doubt looks weak. It’s an easy belief to adopt. But the people around you already know you don’t have all the answers. When you never admit it, they don’t see strength. They see someone who can’t be honest, and they start wondering what else you’re not telling them.
- Take up space. The advice says to spread out, stand tall, and physically claim your place in the room, because confident people take up more space. The problem is that space you take is space someone else loses. Stand over someone’s desk or fill the doorway, and people stop listening and start bracing. That’s exactly what one of my clients learned in the closet conversation.
- Fake it till you make it. This is another piece of really bad advice. The idea is to act confident until you feel confident. It’s well-meaning advice, and it can help you get through a nervous moment. But as a leadership strategy, it backfires. The people you work with have spent years reading bosses, and they’ll notice the gap between who you are and who you’re pretending to be long before you close it.
Here’s what I’ve noticed after years of coaching leaders. Nobody walks out of a meeting thinking, Wow, she really took up space. What people want is to deal with someone who’s authentically kind, generous, considerate, and mature. Someone who’s comfortable in their own skin and grounded in who they are, while also being genuinely inspired to work with the people around them.
The hard part of her story is that she already had much of that. The tactics didn’t add presence. They covered it up.
That kind of commanding presence doesn’t come from a pose. It comes from how you treat the room.
Here’s the subtle shift:
Practice presence instead of performing it.
You don’t need to put on a show or adopt a new persona. You need a few subtle shifts in your attention, assumptions, and actions.
- Don’t speak first. Ask the first question, then listen to the answer.
- Instead of hiding doubt, name it plainly and say what you’ll do about it.
- Instead of taking up space, make space for the quietest person in the room.
- Before you walk in, think about what the people in the room need from you, rather than how you’ll look to them.
None of these will make you look like the loudest person in the meeting. But they’ll make you someone people want to listen to, and that’s what most of us are actually after.
If you want a commanding presence, worry less about commanding the room and more about the people in it.

